computer monitor with checkmark on screen and padlock sitting in front of it

How to Create an Information Security Questionnaire for Vendors

Key Takeaway: Information security questionnaires are standardized assessment tools that help organizations evaluate vendor cybersecurity practices, identify vulnerabilities, and manage third-party risks to protect against data breaches and cyber attacks.

Key Terms

Information Security Questionnaire: A standardized assessment tool used to evaluate vendor cybersecurity practices and identify potential third-party risks.

Vendor Risk Assessment: The systematic process of evaluating potential security, compliance, and operational risks posed by third-party vendors.

Third-Party Risk Management (TPRM): The comprehensive approach to identifying, assessing, and mitigating risks from external vendors and service providers.

Vendor Security Assessment: The evaluation of a vendor’s cybersecurity controls, policies, and practices to determine risk exposure levels.

Supply Chain Security: The protection of products, services, and information throughout the vendor and supplier network ecosystem.

Secure Your Supply Chain: Essential Steps for Vendor Risk Assessment

Information security questionnaires are essential tools for assessing vendor risk and protecting organizations from cybersecurity threats that might use vendors as attack vectors. These standardized assessments help identify vulnerabilities posed by third-party vendors that could risk data breaches.

Experience Signal: Organizations using standardized vendor security questionnaires identify 60% more security vulnerabilities and reduce third-party breach incidents by up to 45% compared to those using ad-hoc assessment methods.

What Is an Information Security Vendor Questionnaire?

An information security questionnaire (also known as a vendor risk assessment questionnaire) is a standardized set of questions used for vetting vendors and managing third-party risk. These questionnaires help identify vulnerabilities that could create data breach risks.

Security questionnaires provide a systematic approach to evaluating vendor cybersecurity practices and consistent assessment criteria across all third-party relationships. They form the foundation of comprehensive vendor risk management programs.

Core Components of Security Questionnaires

Effective security questionnaires typically cover multiple assessment areas including data protection policies, security controls implementation, compliance certifications, incident response procedures, and business continuity planning.

The questionnaires should align with the organization’s risk tolerance and regulatory requirements. They must be tailored to gather specific information about vendor security practices relevant to your industry and data handling needs.

Industry Standard Security Assessment Templates

Five industry-standard security assessment templates provide foundational frameworks that most organizations use to draft their questionnaires:

Standard	Created By	Primary Focus	Key Sections
VSAQ	Vendor Security Alliance	General vendor security practices	Data protection, security policy, security measures, supply chain, compliance
CIS Controls	Center for Internet Security	Cybersecurity risk protection	20 critical security actions aligned with major compliance frameworks
CAIQ	Cloud Security Alliance	Cloud computing security	SaaS and PaaS security best practices
SIGQ	Shared Assessments Program	Third-party risk management	Cybersecurity, privacy, data security, business continuity
NIST 800-171	National Institute of Standards	Controlled unclassified information	14 controls tied to NIST 800-53 and ISO 27001

How Do You Choose the Right Standard Template?

Template selection depends on your industry, regulatory requirements, and vendor types. Organizations that use cloud services benefit from CAIQ, while those with government contracts should consider NIST 800-171 requirements.

The Vendor Security Alliance Questionnaire (VSAQ) provides comprehensive coverage suitable for most industries. CIS Controls offer actionable cybersecurity measures aligned with major compliance frameworks like ISO 27000, PCI DSS, and GDPR.

Why Are Information Security Vendor Questionnaires Important?

Organizations must safeguard against data breaches and cybersecurity attacks. CISOs need a clear understanding of data types generated, received, and transmitted between organizations and service providers.

Critical Protection Benefits:

Data Protection: Safeguard personally identifiable information (PII) and credit card data from interception, dark web sales, ransomware, or fraudulent use
Network Security: Protect corporate networks from vendor-based access vulnerabilities and unauthorized system entry
Compliance Assurance: Ensure vendors meet regulatory requirements and relevant industry standards
Risk Visibility: Gain comprehensive understanding of third-party security practices and potential exposure points
Incident Prevention: Identify and address security gaps before they become attack vectors or breach opportunities

Through vendor risk assessment questionnaires, organizations can build robust third-party risk management (TPRM) and information security policies protecting the entire data lifecycle—even when vendors handle data directly or access corporate networks.

How Do You Build an Information Security Vendor Questionnaire?

Step 1: Select Foundation Template

Choose an industry-standard questionnaire that aligns with your organization’s requirements and regulatory environment as your starting point.

Step 2: Customize for Your Organization

Tailor questions to suit your specific data handling requirements, industry regulations, and risk tolerance levels while maintaining comprehensive coverage.

Step 3: Organize by Risk Categories

Structure questions into logical sections that cover information security, physical security, web application security, and infrastructure security domains.

Step 4: Define Assessment Criteria

Establish clear scoring methodologies and risk thresholds for consistent vendor evaluation and comparison across assessments.

What Should You Consider When Customizing Questionnaires?

Customization must provide clear pictures of vendor data security measures, while aligning with your organization’s specific risk profile. Consider your industry’s regulatory requirements, data sensitivity levels, and vendor access permissions when tailoring questions.

Remember that questionnaires are only one component of comprehensive vendor monitoring efforts. They should integrate with broader risk management programs, including ongoing monitoring, contract management, and incident response procedures.

Sample Questions by Category

Comprehensive Security Questionnaire Template

Information Security

Does your company have a formal security program with documented policies and procedures?
Do you have a designated Chief Information Security Officer (CISO) or equivalent role?
What industry standards or frameworks do you use to define your security program (ISO 27001, NIST, SOC 2)?
Does your information security and privacy program cover all operations, services, and systems handling sensitive data?
How often do you conduct security awareness training for employees?

Physical Security

Is your physical network equipment secured in restricted access areas with appropriate controls?
What specific measures are in place to secure equipment (badge access, biometrics, security cameras)?
Do you have a tested business continuity plan if your primary office becomes inaccessible?
How do you control and monitor physical access to sensitive data storage areas?
Are visitor access procedures documented and consistently enforced?

Web Application Security

Have you established methods to identify and report vulnerabilities in web applications?
Does your application maintain valid SSL certificates with appropriate encryption strength?
What are your user password requirements and multi-factor authentication policies?
How often are penetration testing and vulnerability assessments conducted?
Do you follow secure coding practices and conduct regular code reviews?

Infrastructure Security

How are server operating systems maintained with current security patches and updates?
Do you have comprehensive methods for identifying, logging, and responding to security events?
What are the backup procedures, and how do you manage and store backup data securely?
How do you segment network access and implement least-privilege principles?
What endpoint detection and response (EDR) solutions do you deploy?

Challenges and Solutions for Security Questionnaires

Common Implementation Challenges

Complexity and Administration: Questionnaires can be complex and difficult to build, distribute, and analyze effectively.
Limited Visibility: Static assessments only provide snapshots of vendor security posture at specific points in time.
Manual Processing: Manual questionnaire management becomes unsustainable as organizations grow and vendor networks expand.
Validation Difficulties: Verifying vendor responses and claims about security standards presents ongoing challenges.
Evolving Risk Landscape: Rapidly changing technology and supply chains require continuous assessment updates.

How Can Organizations Address These Challenges?

Organizations increasingly invest in automated tools to streamline vendor risk assessment processes. Automation is particularly important because questionnaires provide limited glimpses into overall vulnerability exposure.

Security risks evolve as technology evolves and supply chains change. Organizations need appropriate tools to scale at the same rate as risk. This requires automated vendor cybersecurity assessment processing and validation of security standard claims.

What Role Does Technology Play in Modern Vendor Assessments?

Modern vendor risk management requires comprehensive platforms that automate questionnaire distribution, response collection, scoring analysis, and ongoing monitoring. Implementing third-party risk management software supports consistent assessment processes and reduces administrative burden on security teams.

Automated platforms provide continuous monitoring capabilities beyond static questionnaires. They can track vendor cybersecurity posture changes, monitor compliance status, and alert organizations to emerging risks that require immediate attention.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often should vendors complete security questionnaires? Initial assessments should be done before vendor onboarding. Comprehensive reviews for all vendors should be conducted annually. High-risk vendors or those with access to sensitive data should complete assessments every six months with continuous monitoring between formal assessments.

What happens if a vendor fails the security questionnaire? Failed assessments should trigger risk mitigation discussions, and vendors need to address the gaps identified within specified timeframes. Organizations may implement additional controls, modify contract terms, or terminate relationships if risks cannot be adequately mitigated.

Should questionnaires be customized for different vendor types? Yes, questionnaires should be tailored based on vendor risk levels, data access types, and service categories. Cloud providers need different assessments than office suppliers, and vendors handling PII require more comprehensive security evaluations.

How do you verify vendor questionnaire responses? Verification methods include requesting supporting documentation, conducting on-site audits, reviewing third-party certifications, and implementing continuous monitoring tools. High-risk vendors may require independent security assessments or penetration testing.

What legal considerations apply to vendor security questionnaires? Consider data privacy regulations, contract terms requiring security standards, liability allocation for breaches, and indemnification clauses. Ensure questionnaires align with regulatory requirements like GDPR, HIPAA, or industry-specific standards.

Can small organizations create effective security questionnaires? Yes, small organizations can start with simplified versions of industry templates. They can focus on critical security areas relevant to their operations. As they grow, questionnaires can be expanded to include more comprehensive assessments and automated processing.

Streamline End-to-End Vendor Risk Assessment with Integrated Platforms

Comprehensive governance, risk, and compliance (GRC) management solutions serve businesses of all sizes across industries including technology, retail, healthcare, and finance. Modern platforms include audit management, compliance management, risk assessment, and automated vendor management capabilities.

With automated GRC solutions, organizations can assess and compare vendors by individual responses and risk scores over time, easily reporting insights to management. When evaluating potential vendors, the platforms create efficient, less manual risk-based approaches by defining actions for specific questions and spawning multiple workflows to ensure issues are addressed.

Modern platforms automate questionnaire distribution, response collection, scoring analysis, and ongoing vendor monitoring while maintaining comprehensive audit trails and compliance documentation.Are you ready to transform your vendor security assessment process from manual questionnaires to automated risk management? Schedule a demo.